Milburn wants to bring that figure down to 5% by 2036. Part of the answer, his report proposes, is changes to benefits for under-25s, including restricting access to some existing disability benefits. Big Issue has written a full summary of the proposed benefits changes here, which have been slammed by charities as “frightening.”
But Milburn claims that these cuts would be justified by new employment support. So what would such support look like?
What legal guarantees should NEETs have?
The review proposes a new Young People’s Guarantee, made up of two legal commitments: an Opportunity Guarantee and a Support Guarantee.
Keep reading the journalism that powers our mission
Register free to continue and learn more about the stories, campaigns and the support we provide, helping people facing poverty across the UK.
The Opportunity Guarantee would give young people access to a range of routes into participation, including a job, college place, apprenticeship, work placement or supported employment. It could also include structured volunteering and help to start a business.
The second commitment, the Support Guarantee, would bring together the health and employment help needed to make those opportunities possible.
The two guarantees would be delivered through a new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS), with a service in every area of England.
“That’s a single front door for young people to be guaranteed some form of work, training, or or labor market participation,” explains Alice Martin, from the Work Foundation.
“It will feel like a gear change. I think young people now, they won’t have felt this level of attention and government access and support before. So, it is going to feel like a step change.”
Young people would have a named adviser and a personalised participation plan, bringing together the opportunities and support they need.
The report sets out a timetable: a young person should meet an adviser within 14 days of contacting the service, have a plan within four weeks, and have something “substantive” under way within four months. That could mean starting college or training, taking up work experience, or moving into a job.
If a young person remains NEET after 12 months despite engaging with the support on offer, and paid work is realistically possible, the state should secure them a real, paid six-month job, Milburn recommends.
The legal right wouldn’t mean kids suing the state, explains Martin.
“Authorities already have a statutory duty to monitor young people – for example, to know that they’re participating in compulsory education. So the legal right is an extension of that statutory duty to ensure provision for young people – pushed up to a slightly older age, and that provision will be more varied,” she said. “It will have a kind of menu approach, so it will include things like employment opportunities, but also education, training, and other forms of pastoral support as well.”
Read more:
How much will it cost?
Milburn proposes an initial £500m investment in 2027 to start building the new system.
By 2036-37, annual government investment in the wider package – including the guarantees, employer incentives, health, education and skills reforms – is expected to reach £5.8bn.
The review estimates this would be offset by £3.6bn in savings from welfare reform and £2.4bn in increased tax revenues and reduced benefit payments as more young people enter work. Together, that would mean an annual net saving of around £200m.
But the Resolution Foundation has warned that the proposals will require significant investment.
“The Milburn Review shows that for too long Britain has delivered support for young people on the cheap – from cuts to further education to threadbare mental health services to employment support that pales in comparison to what other countries offer,” said Ruth Curtice, chief executive of the Resolution Foundation
“Turning this around will require significant investment, through new legislation and a young people centred spending review next year.”
The report also proposes incentives to encourage employers to take on young people. Employers would receive £3,000 for hiring someone who has been NEET for six months, with an additional £2,000 for taking on someone facing greater barriers, such as a care leaver or disabled young person. Smaller businesses could also receive an extra payment.
Milburn also suggests reducing employer national insurance costs for 21- to 24-year-olds starting in retail and hospitality. If fiscal conditions allow, the threshold at which employers begin paying NI for these workers would rise from £5,000 to £10,000 over five years.
Labour’s decision to increase national insurance contributions from employers has proven controversial and Milburn notes that it is a factor in rising employment costs.
Isn’t there already a Youth Guarantee?
The Keir Starmer government introduced its own Youth Guarantee in 2024, promising young people access to further education, help finding work or an apprenticeship.
It has since expanded the offer to include a Jobs Guarantee, providing eligible 18- to 24-year-olds with six months of paid work, alongside a £3,000 grant for employers. Other measures include Youth Hubs, work experience and Jobcentre work coaches.
But Milburn argues that the current offer is fragmented, with different schemes and services operating separately. His proposal would bring them together through one Youth Opportunity Service and make access to support a legal entitlement.
He also wants the offer to reach young people who are not claiming benefits. In July, the Work and Pensions Committee found that 44% of NEET young people were not claiming benefits and therefore couldn’t access many of its schemes
There’s also education support. The report proposes 150,000 additional further education places for 18- to 24-year-olds, 25,000 initial pre-apprenticeship places and doubling the number of young people completing apprenticeships over the next decade to 270,000 placements.
Martin urged the government to take the Milburn proposals on board – not to merely pick a few of the cheaper proposals.
“These are recommendations to government. So government doesn’t have to take them all on. And one of our cautions is that the government ideally won’t cherry pick from them, and just pick things that it feels are doable now, or maybe have less of a cost attached now,” she said.
“Ideally, these proposals should be taken as a package and and even expanded on where possible.”
Why are so many young people NEET?
Research by the Work Foundation found that the number of starter jobs accessible to first-time entrants has fallen by 49% over the past decade. There is now around one starter vacancy for every three young people who are NEET.
Employers face rising costs when hiring, while artificial intelligence is also beginning to automate some of the entry-level administrative tasks that once gave young people a way into work.
“Delivering on the proposed Opportunity Guarantee for young people in the current labour market will require substantial upfront investment, not just in employment and health support, but in supporting the creation of more secure, flexible starter jobs too,” said Ben Harrison, director of the Work Foundation at Lancaster University.
“The reality is that NEET young people can’t access jobs that simply don’t exist.”
Labour market statistics, also released by the Office for National Statistics on Tuesday (17 November), found overall job vacacnies have fallen to 690,000, the lowest level since 2014 outside of pandemic years.
Health is another major barrier. The review says poor mental and physical health have become significant drivers of young people’s economic inactivity.
“No credible strategy to improve young people’s participation can succeed without addressing health-related barriers to work and education head-on,” said Alison Ismail, director of health and inequalities at the Health Foundation.
“The proposed Youth Opportunity Service could be central to achieving this shift.”
The report argues that young people need more than help finding a vacancy. They may also need support with travel, work clothes, identity documents, housing, debt or health problems.
That is particularly important for young people leaving care, who may be trying to manage rent, bills and the search for a job without the family support or financial safety net that other young people have.
“Government has a particular responsibility to young people who have grown up in its care. That responsibility should include a credible route into paid work, with the support to make it last,” said Russell Winnard, chief executive of the Drive Forward Foundation.
“Aged just 18, care leavers are often managing rent, bills and the search for a job without a trusted network of support or a reliable financial safety net, delays and gaps in support can have serious consequences. We must do more to prevent the negative impact of not being in work escalating and becoming entrenched.”
Winnard said a Care Leaver Jobs Guarantee should include a paid opportunity, help with the practical costs of starting work and a trusted person to turn to if problems arise.
“Getting through the door is the beginning. Being able to stay, learn and progress is what changes someone’s future.”
Overall, the review estimates that its proposals could help around 440,000 young people into sustained work by 2036.
Martin said that bringing down the overall number of NEETs is important – but only tells part of the story.
“Yes, we can bring young people out of NEET status by getting them onto a training course and counting them slightly differently,” she said.
“But what will they be experiencing two three years down the line? Will they have a good job then? Will they know where they’re heading in life? I think that’s going to take more government action, government attention, and it’s something that will be harder to ultimately measure.”
Do you have a story to tell or opinions to share about this? Get in touch and tell us more.
Change a vendor’s life.
Buy from your local Big Issue vendor every week – and always take the magazine. It’s how vendors earn with dignity and move forward.
You can also support online:
Subscribe to the magazine or support our work with a monthly gift. Your support helps vendors earn, learn and thrive while strengthening our frontline services.
Thank you for standing with Big Issue vendors.